I took my usual medium (a women’s size 6–8, according to Brooklinen’s size chart, which recommends sizing up if you want a more generous fit). It fits well, as I can tighten the waist tie as ...

With that in mind, I reached out to a number of women with admirable tastes — including stylists, designers, and brand founders — about the button-downs they wear most often. I tried a few of ...